Auto Insurance

Low Rates, Local Agents, and Complete Peace of Mind

Learn More


We Want to Help Protect You During All Stages of Life

Learn More


Specialized Coverage You Need to do Business with Confidence

Learn More

Your Local Goshen Independent Insurance Agency

Reliance-Menno-Hursh Insurance Group specializes in Auto, Homeowners, Life, Commercial, Business, Farm, and Crop Insurance.

Welcome to Reliance-Menno-Hursh Insurance Group! We have two locations to conveniently serve you. Reliance-Menno-Hursh Insurance Group is located in Goshen, Indiana, and Hursh Insurance Agency is located in Syracuse, Indiana. Between the two agencies, we have over 100 years combined insurance experience among our staff. Both agencies offer Auto, Homeowners, Life, Commercial, Business, Farm, and Crop Insurance. We work with reputable insurance companies who share our commitment to great service and quality coverage at an affordable price.

If you are a current client, we sincerely thank you for trusting us as your insurance agent. Feel free to call or stop by either agency. We are available to answer your questions, make changes to your policies, and review your coverage. If you just want to stop by and say hello, we welcome your visit!

If you are not a current client, we would love the opportunity to sit down and review your current policies and insurance needs. We ask questions. We listen. We provide a free quote and an explanation of coverage tailored to meet your personal or business insurance needs.


Customer Reviews

See All Reviews


Property/casualty price increases grow

POSTED: Thu, 22 Aug 2019 16:16:00

Pricing increases for accounts of all sizes increased an average of 5.2%, compared with an average of 3.5% in first-quarter 2019 and 2.4% in fourth-quarter 2018, according to results from The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers’ second-quarter 2019 commercial property/casualty market survey.... Read Article

Injured Uber driver not covered for auto accident on return trip

POSTED: Thu, 22 Aug 2019 13:31:00

An Uber driver is not entitled to insurance coverage for injuries suffered in an accident that occurred after she dropped off a passenger, says a federal appeals court in affirming a lower court ruling.... Read Article

Dental insurance organization on tooth fairy reward

POSTED: Thu, 22 Aug 2019 12:49:00

On Tooth Fairy Day Thursday, one might ponder in these current times: How much should she put under the pillow?... Read Article



Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.

Reliance-Menno-Hursh Insurance Group Provides Auto, Homeowners, Life, Commercial, Business, Farm, and Crop Insurance to all of Indiana, Including Goshen, Elkhart, Middlebury, Shipshewana, Bristol, Syracuse, North Webster, Warsaw, New Paris, and Millersburg.

© Copyright 2019, Reliance-Menno-Hursh Insurance Group | Privacy Statement